• Home
  • Our Story
    • Leadership
    • Our Voyage
    • Our Vessels
    • Sustainability
    • Rob Stewart
    • Don Walsh
  • Missions
    • E.A.R. Foundation
    • R/V Audacity
    • Audax Ventus
    • Expedition Luminescence
    • Beluga Crisis
    • Red Quill Society
    • The Hauntline
  • Programs
    • Film & VR Programs
    • Subsea Programs
    • Make-A-Wish
    • Hope Spot Survies
    • Collegiate Ecosystem
    • Research On Demand
  • Opportunities
    • Audacity Check
    • Join Our Crew
    • Citizen Science Crew
    • Collaborative Crew
    • VIP Explorer Circle
  • Sponsors & Donors
    • Please Donate
    • Sponsorship or In-Kind
  • Login
    • Crew Login
    • Board Login
  • More
    • Home
    • Our Story
      • Leadership
      • Our Voyage
      • Our Vessels
      • Sustainability
      • Rob Stewart
      • Don Walsh
    • Missions
      • E.A.R. Foundation
      • R/V Audacity
      • Audax Ventus
      • Expedition Luminescence
      • Beluga Crisis
      • Red Quill Society
      • The Hauntline
    • Programs
      • Film & VR Programs
      • Subsea Programs
      • Make-A-Wish
      • Hope Spot Survies
      • Collegiate Ecosystem
      • Research On Demand
    • Opportunities
      • Audacity Check
      • Join Our Crew
      • Citizen Science Crew
      • Collaborative Crew
      • VIP Explorer Circle
    • Sponsors & Donors
      • Please Donate
      • Sponsorship or In-Kind
    • Login
      • Crew Login
      • Board Login
  • Sign In

  • My Account
  • Signed in as:

  • filler@godaddy.com


  • My Account
  • Sign out

Signed in as:

filler@godaddy.com

  • Home
  • Our Story
    • Leadership
    • Our Voyage
    • Our Vessels
    • Sustainability
    • Rob Stewart
    • Don Walsh
  • Missions
    • E.A.R. Foundation
    • R/V Audacity
    • Audax Ventus
    • Expedition Luminescence
    • Beluga Crisis
    • Red Quill Society
    • The Hauntline
  • Programs
    • Film & VR Programs
    • Subsea Programs
    • Make-A-Wish
    • Hope Spot Survies
    • Collegiate Ecosystem
    • Research On Demand
  • Opportunities
    • Audacity Check
    • Join Our Crew
    • Citizen Science Crew
    • Collaborative Crew
    • VIP Explorer Circle
  • Sponsors & Donors
    • Please Donate
    • Sponsorship or In-Kind
  • Login
    • Crew Login
    • Board Login

Account


  • My Account
  • Sign out


  • Sign In
  • My Account

BELUGA SANCTUARY INITIATIVE

Please Donate Now

All donors and patrons are automatically entered into our monthly draw for a chance to spend a week at sea as part of our crew.

Draw Information

A Path Forward For the Marineland Belugas

A National, Indigenous-Led, Multi-Sanctuary Future for Canada’s Captive Whales

Led by: Expedition Audacity Research Foundation in partnership with: Dove Joans (“DolphinGirl”), marine scientists, Indigenous knowledge holders, cetacean veterinarians, and coastal communities.


Why This Matters


Canada is now responsible for 30 beluga whales and 4 dolphins who cannot be released directly into the wild.


These whales were born into human care.


They have never developed the hunting, navigation, or social survival skills required for open-ocean life.


Keeping them in concrete tanks is no longer ethical, sustainable, or culturally acceptable.
But releasing them abruptly into the ocean would be cruel and fatal.


We now stand at a defining moment:

Either we build sanctuaries — or we allow these whales to disappear quietly.
We refuse to let that be their future.
 

Our Solution: A Three-Sanctuary Network

No single sanctuary site in Canada can safely or humanely house all belugas.


Their health, social bonds, stress profiles, and long-term wellbeing require multiple sites, each with distinct roles and environmental strengths.


The future is a network, not a single enclosure.


A Sanctuary Must Have Two Linked Spaces


All three sanctuaries will be built using a dual-habitat model:


Lagoon Pool (4–5 acres)                                           

- A protected, semi-contained, familiar environment

- Used for medical care, stress regulation, and gradual acclimation

- Calm, predictable, safe — no pressure to leave

- Some whales may remain here permanently if they choose


Sea-Pen Ocean Enclosure

- A large, open-ocean living space within natural waters

- Used for social exploration, natural behaviours, and life in the sea

- Accessed by choice through a controlled gate

- Only for whales who adapt comfortably 


We do NOT force whales into ocean enclosures.
Choice is the foundation of sanctuary.
This is where Iceland has struggled — and where we refuse to repeat past harm.


The Three Sanctuary Sites


1. Newfoundland South Coast Fjord Sanctuary (First Relocations)


Strengths

  • Deep, quiet, naturally sheltered fjords
     
  • Clean seabed (no industrial heavy-metal legacy)
     
  • Cold, stable water ideal for beluga physiology
     
  • Strong potential for Indigenous-led governance
     

Capacity: ~10–14 belugas
Role: First relocation site; long-term home for medically or socially sensitive whales.
Includes: Lagoon + sea-pen ocean habitat


2. Mingan Archipelago, Québec

Rehabilitation & Cultural Stewardship Sanctuary


Strengths

  • Sheltered island channels & gentle tides
     
  • Existing Indigenous marine stewardship and research presence
     
  • Strong ecological baselines and food-web stability
     

Capacity: ~10–12 belugas
Role: Rehabilitation, social re-bonding, and culturally rooted long-term sanctuary care.
Includes: Lagoon + adaptive ocean sea-pen habitat


3. Pacific Sanctuary — Broughton Archipelago (BC)

Nuchatlaht & Kwakwaka’wakw Waters


Strengths

  • Former aquaculture systems ready for conversion
     
  • Deep calm inlets sheltered from Pacific swell
     
  • Proven Indigenous-led marine restoration track record
     

Capacity: ~8–10 belugas + all 4 dolphins
Role: Pacific sanctuary, interspecies learning centre, and ethical research hub.
Includes: Lagoon + multi-pen ocean habitat structures


Key Principles

  • Indigenous-led co-governance — from planning to daily care
     
  • Independent veterinary & welfare oversight
     
  • Regenerative, climate-conscious infrastructure
     
  • No shows. No performance. No commercial exhibition.
     

Whales are not attractions.
They are sovereign emotional beings — nations of minds.
 

Beluga Sanctuary Transition Timeline

Phase 1 — Immediate Stabilisation at Marineland


Months 0–6

  • Assume operational care oversight through cooperative or appointed-trustee model
     
  • Full medical & behavioural assessments
     
  • Identify first transfer cohort
     
  • Begin transport conditioning & social group preparation
     

Phase 2 — Newfoundland Sanctuary + First Transfers


Months 6–12

  • Construct 4–5 acre transitional Lagoon Pool
     
  • Connect to sea-pen only once whales choose and show readiness
     
  • Move first 8–10 whales
     
  • Sanctuary becomes operational and living — not conceptual
     

Phase 3 — Mingan and Broughton Sanctuaries Online

Months 9–24


Mingan (QC)           12–18 months         Social rehabilitation & cultural care sanctuary

Broughton (BC)      18–24 months         Pacific sanctuary & dolphin-inclusive research hub 


By Month 24:
All belugas have a safe, humane, long-term ocean home pathway.


Partner Spotlight

Dove Joans — “Dolphin Girl”


Internationally respected marine mammal welfare advocate, trauma-transition specialist, and storyteller.


Her lived expertise in emotional care and interspecies psychology is foundational to this initiative.

Together, we bring: Science + Empathy + Story.
 

Our Ask


We are now assembling:

  • Marine engineers & ocean habitat designers
     
  • Cetacean veterinarians & behavioural specialists
     
  • Indigenous governance partners at each site
     
  • Environmental research teams
     
  • Funders committed to multi-year stewardship, not headlines
     

If that includes you—
this is the moment to step forward. 


A National, Indigenous-Led, Multi-Sanctuary Future for Canada’s Captive Whales


Belugas taught us wonder.

Now we owe them peace.

Our concerns with the Nova Scotia Sanctuary Site

We respect the dedication and compassion of those who have worked for years to establish the proposed sanctuary at Port Hilford Bay. Their intentions are sincere, and their commitment to improving the lives of captive whales deserves recognition.


However, we cannot support the placement of belugas in this location due to environmental conditions that pose direct health risks to the whales. Nor can we support the use of public funds to develop a site that does not meet the behavioral, medical, and psychological needs of belugas who have lived their entire lives in human care.


The Core Issue: Heavy Metal Contamination


Port Hilford Bay lies within the historic Wine Harbour gold-mining district, where arsenic and mercury tailings from the 19th and early 20th centuries settled into the seabed.


Environmental assessments confirm that:

  • Heavy metals remain present in the sediment
     
  • They are stable only if undisturbed
     
  • Belugas naturally dig, nudge, and interact with seafloor sediment
     

Therefore:

Placing belugas in this location could expose them to toxins through their own natural behaviors.
 

This is not theoretical.
It is established marine ecology and animal welfare science.


The Iceland Lesson: Sanctuary Must Include a Pool / Lagoon Space


Recent updates from the Iceland sanctuary have shown that:

  • Some whales adjust well to sea pen environments
     
  • Others never fully adapt
     
  • Some require a protected lagoon or pool-style enclosure to feel safe long-term
     

In other words:

Not every beluga is ready for full ocean exposure — even inside a sea pen.
 

Sanctuary design must include:

  • A transitional lagoon
     
  • With controlled water conditions
     
  • Where whales can retreat when overwhelmed, ill, or socially stressed
     

The Nova Scotia site has no such space in its operational design.


There is no fallback habitat, no quiet protected pool, no choice-based refuge.


Without this, the sanctuary may recreate the same psychological stress patterns captivity already caused — simply in a different location.

A sanctuary must offer freedom and safety, not just seawater.


Our Position


We cannot support the Nova Scotia site or the allocation of public funds to it because:

  • The seabed is not safe
     
  • There is no dedicated lagoon space for whales who cannot adapt to the pen
     
  • Long-term health and welfare cannot be guaranteed
     

This is not ideological.


It is biological, psychological, ethical, and responsible.


We Support Sanctuary — But Sanctuary Must Be Done Right


A sanctuary must:

  • Place whale welfare first
     
  • Be Indigenous-led from governance to daily operations
     
  • Provide clean, stable, acoustically suitable marine environments
     
  • Include choice-based habitat models, not forced exposure
     
  • Offer lifelong care, not symbolic relocation
     

If we are to move belugas out of tanks,
we cannot move them into risk.


Our Commitment: A National Sanctuary Network Built for Their Real Needs


We are advancing three sanctuary locations that meet the necessary environmental, cultural, and psychological care conditions.


All three sites are designed with:

  • Holding lagoons
     
  • Sea-pen access by choice
     
  • Veterinary monitoring capacity
     
  • Indigenous governance models
     

Together, they provide:

  • Safe living spaces
     
  • Geographic distribution
     
  • Cultural belonging
     
  • Capacity for all remaining belugas
     

The Principle Is Simple


If sanctuary means safety,
then safety cannot be compromised.


Not for sentiment.
Not for urgency.
Not for optics.
Not even for hope.


Sanctuary must honour the whales first.

To join the Sanctuary Working Group, collaborate, or support:

South Coast Fjord Sanctuary (near Burgeo, NL)

Broughton Archipelago B.C. (Thompson/Bond Sound, BC))

Mingan Archipelago, Québec (Gulf of St. Lawrence)

Mingan Archipelago, Québec (Gulf of St. Lawrence)

Broughton Archipelago B.C. (Thompson/Bond Sound, BC))

Mingan Archipelago, Québec (Gulf of St. Lawrence)

Broughton Archipelago B.C. (Thompson/Bond Sound, BC))

Broughton Archipelago B.C. (Thompson/Bond Sound, BC))

Broughton Archipelago B.C. (Thompson/Bond Sound, BC))

Potential Sanctuary Sites

Download PDF
Download PDF

How We Got Here:

A Brief History of Marineland and Its Belugas

Marineland opened in 1961 in Niagara Falls, Ontario — not as a theme park, but as a small roadside attraction called Marine Wonderland and Animal Farm, founded by John Holer, a Slovenian immigrant and entrepreneur. Holer envisioned it as a place where families could get close to animals they would never otherwise encounter.


Through the 1970s and 1980s, Marineland grew rapidly. The whale stadium was built. The park’s signature song “Everyone Loves Marineland” played across Ontario radio.


For many children — myself included — Marineland was the first time we looked into the eye of a whale and felt the world change a little.


But behind the nostalgia, the world was shifting.


The Age of Captivity


When Marineland expanded, captivity was still seen as education. It was believed whales could inspire public love for oceans. And for a time, that was true.


But we learned.
The science evolved.
Public ethics evolved.
Understanding deepened.


By the 1990s and 2000s, global research began to show that cetaceans — whales, dolphins, belugas — are not simply animals, but highly social, culturally transmitted, emotionally intelligent beings. They form lifelong bonds, dialects, memory maps, grief practices, even humour.


The tanks stayed the same size.


The science did not.


The Turning Point


Reports of animal welfare concerns accumulated over time — from former trainers, veterinarians, government inspectors, and journalists.


Public trust began to fracture.


Canada’s conscience shifted.


In 2019, after years of pressure from scientists, Indigenous leaders, former trainers, NGOs, and the public, the federal government passed Bill S-203, effectively banning the breeding and display of cetaceans in captivity.


Suddenly, Marineland was no longer a park.


It became a holding place for animals who could not legally leave, and could not be released.

No one wrote a plan for what comes next.


And so the whales — especially the belugas, most of whom were born at Marineland — have existed in a kind of legal and moral limbo.


The Current Crisis


Today, Marineland houses:


  • ~30 beluga whales
     
  • 4 bottlenose dolphins
     

These animals cannot survive in the wild.


Their immune systems, social learning patterns, and foraging instincts were shaped in tanks, not seas.


Exportation was recently blocked by the federal government — closing the door to foreign transfer.
The park has signaled financial instability.


Concerns about veterinary care have resurfaced repeatedly.


The result is a historic moral responsibility:


We cannot leave the whales where they are.


We cannot release them into the wild.


And one sanctuary — even when completed — only has space for a fraction of them.


Which is how we got here.
To this moment.
To this chance.


The Opportunity in Front of Us


We now stand at a crossroads Canada has never faced before:


Do we let these whales fade quietly into the past?


Or do we build a future that honours what they are — and what they have meant to us?

This is where the three-sanctuary solution comes in.


Not as protest.
Not as punishment.
But as responsibility.


Because if Marineland was the story of how we loved the ocean without knowing how,
then the sanctuaries are the story of how we love the ocean differently now.


The Past Is Written.

The Future Is Not.


And we have one last chance to write it well.

Copyright © 2025 Expedition Audacity - All Rights Reserved.

Expedition Audacity Research Foundation - E.A.R Foundation  33-3246352 - 501(c)3 - Dover, Delaware.

11006126 Canada ltd -  Expedition Audacity Research Foundation - Fondation de recherche Expédition Audace - 1726380-5

  • Leadership
  • Our Vessels
  • Sustainability
  • Rob Stewart
  • E.A.R. Foundation
  • R/V Audacity
  • Expedition Luminescence
  • Film & VR Programs
  • Subsea Programs
  • Hope Spot Survies
  • Research On Demand
  • Audacity Check
  • Citizen Science Crew
  • Please Donate
  • Sponsorship or In-Kind

Powered by

This website uses cookies.

 

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your experience on our website. If you accept the use of cookies, your data will be combined with the data of all other users.


RejectAccept